This historical mystery review, Untrue Till Death: Murder in the 17th Century (Master Mercurius Mystery) by Graham Brack, first appeared in the February 2021 Historical Novels Review.
A Historical Mystery with an Intellectual Puzzle
Set in 1674, The Netherlands, this second in series offers an intricate, intellectual murder puzzle to solve amidst the academic debates of University of Leiden and the intrigues surrounding William of Orange’s leadership. By series premise, Mercurius, philosophy master, is writing his memoirs. This time, his remembered tale concerns the “accidental” death of a colleague who fell down some stairs.
A Philosophical Sleuth
The novel’s plot flows from there as William forces Mercurius into investigating political conspiracies, which leads to yet another murder and a too-close cooperation with a torturer—also, a romantic entanglement that Mercurius, as a hidden Catholic priest, shouldn’t participate in, but he does admire a beautiful woman.
Distinctive Voice
The dominant charm of Brack’s writing lies in Mercurius’s deadpan voice. He combines references to cerebral philosophical arguments (in accessible ways) with a self-deprecating, cynical take on human nature. In an early scene with the rector of the university, for example, Mercurius realizes that he’s being set up for the unenviable job of giving a lecture to their students warning against the evils of visiting whores. He thinks to himself, “I was convinced that in a contest between my moral philosophy seminars and an evening between the ample breasts of Fat Lysbeth, I was unlikely to come out on top, if you’ll pardon the expression.” Here and elsewhere Mercurius’s inner language shades into contemporary idiom, but humor carries it off for the most part.
Brack also vividly depicts the Dutch cities and countryside, along with details of daily life and academic peculiarities. He takes us back to a time and place rarely covered by historical mysteries with authority and obvious depth of knowledge. A pleasing package of history, philosophy, and murderous fun.
Availability
Untrue Till Death is the second in the Mercurius series. I hadn’t read the first book and did not struggle to understand what was going on, but you may want to start with the first book, Death in Delft.
Graham Brack’s website.
Buy Untrue Till Death on Amazon (affiliate link)
Here for my review of a historical mystery set in 18th century London, Derby, and France.